Tuesday, 25 November 2014 / TRUTH-OUT.ORG

Black Caucus: #StandWithKeith to End Gaza Blockade

Wednesday, 06 August 2014 11:35 By Robert Naiman, Truthout | Op-Ed

2014 806 keath stCongressman Keath Ellison, co-chair of the Congressional Progressive Caucus (Photo: Aaron Landry / Flickr)On July 29, Congressional Progressive Caucus Co-Chair Keith Ellison did something unique for a member of Congress. He published an op-ed in The Washington Post calling for ending the economic blockade on 1.8 million Palestinians in Gaza, noting that most of the victims of the blockade were women and children.

As of this writing, Representative Ellison stands alone among members of Congress in calling for the economic blockade on civilians in Gaza to end.

"Every schoolboy knows" that the so-called "pro-Israel lobby," i.e. the lobby pushing for US policy on any issue of interest to the Israeli government to be determined to the greatest extent possible by the Israeli Likud party, has tremendous influence in Washington and especially in Congress. The generally accepted shorthand for this pro-Likud lobby is "AIPAC." (It's common practice to use the term "AIPAC" to refer to the pro-Likud lobby generically, including such groups as the (so-called) Anti-Defamation League (ADL) and the American Jewish Committee (AJC), rather than merely to the activities of the American Israel Public Affairs Committee per se, much as one uses the term "Xerox" to mean "copy." I will follow this practice here, using the term "AIPAC" to refer to the pro-Likud lobby more generally.)

But here is a crucial fact that is largely unacknowledged: Until now, there is no consistent, strategic, coordinated effort by DC-focused reformists to reduce the harm caused by AIPAC to US policy on the Israel-Palestine issue, with the goal of opening political space for concrete measures to support a realistic diplomatic resolution of issues related to the Israel-Palestine conflict, similar to the coordinated efforts that have opened political space for diplomatic efforts to resolve the US-Iran conflict over Iran's nuclear program. There is a vacuum of pragmatic, reformist leadership to try to limit AIPAC's destructive influence on US policy towards Israel-Palestine.

If there were not such a vacuum, Keith Ellison would not be standing alone. 

On the one hand, there are reformist groups. Unfortunately, at this juncture, the historic fulcrum of these groups appears to be too obsessed with getting the approval of pro-AIPAC Jewish communal institutions to be relied on to consistently lead a reformist effort that moves the ball forward in Washington on Israel-Palestine. On the other hand, there are non-reformist groups on the left, which are incapable of leading strategically because they are obsessed with quixotic fantasies of cutting US military aid to Israel, or of opposing AIPAC "yay Israel" resolutions that are unstoppable. These so-called "strategies" don't pass the minimal "one member of Congress" test for a non-quixotic DC strategy. The "one member of Congress" test for a non-quixotic DC strategy is: Could you get one member of Congress to lead it? If not, then you're not on the playing field of Washington, and have no hope of getting there.

Quixotic efforts are counterproductive over the long term to engagement and mobilization. If you mobilize people for a quixotic strategy, they're likely to be discouraged when the strategy predictably goes down in flames. They're likely to conclude that engagement is useless, but it was the pursuit of a quixotic strategy that caused their demoralization, not engagement per se. When people win, they do more. When they lose, they do less. It's a moral responsibility of a strategist to try to create opportunities for people to win.

Pushing to end the economic blockade of 1.8 million Palestinian human beings in Gaza is passing the "one member of Congress" test, because Rep. Keith Ellison is in the house. So here's a strategy that could potentially be on the playing field of Washington right now: Let's try to get other members of Congress to #StandWithKeith in favor of ending the economic blockade on 1.8 million Palestinians in Gaza.

We have to start somewhere. Where should we begin?

Twenty-seven members of the House have two things in common:

1) like Keith Ellison, they signed the July 2013 Dent-Price letter backing the Obama administration's diplomatic engagement with Iran, in defiance of AIPAC, and 

2) like Keith Ellison, they are members of the Congressional Black Caucus (CBC).

Why is this group of 27 members of Congress so special?

When Ellison sent a letter on July 18, calling for intensifying US diplomacy to end the war in Gaza, two-thirds of the signers were CBC members (like Ellison) who had signed the Dent-Price letter. Twenty-eight (67 percent) of the 42 House members of the CBC (including Ellison) signed the Dent-Price letter. So, while CBC signers of the Dent-Price letter comprised 6 percent of the House, they comprised 67 percent of the signers of the Ellison cease-fire letter. That's why these 27 members of the House are special.


Here they are, with their districts and some geography:

Karen Bass (CA-37) (Los Angeles/Culver City)
Sanford D. Bishop, Jr. (GA-02) (SW Georgia, Columbus-Cordele-Bainbridge)
André Carson (IN-07) (Indianapolis)
Donna M. Christensen (VI) (Virgin Islands)
Wm. Lacy Clay (MO-01) (St. Louis)
Emanuel Cleaver, II (MO-05) (Kansas City)
James E. Clyburn (SC-06) (SE South Carolina, Charleston-Columbia)
John Conyers, Jr. (MI-13) (Detroit)
Elijah E. Cummings (MD-07) (Baltimore)
Danny K. Davis (IL-07) (Chicago-Oak Park)
Donna F. Edwards (MD-04) (Prince George's, Montgomery, Anne Arundel Counties)
Chaka Fattah (PA-02) (Philadelphia)
Alcee L. Hastings (FL-20) (Miami)
Sheila Jackson Lee (TX-18) (Houston)
Eddie Bernice Johnson (TX-30) (Dallas)
Hank Johnson (GA-04) (Atlanta-Decatur, DeKalb County)
Robin Kelly (IL-02) (Chicago-Kankakee)
Barbara Lee (CA-13) (Berkeley-Oakland)
John Lewis (GA-05) (Atlanta)
Gregory W. Meeks (NY-06) (Queens)
Gwen Moore (WI-04) (Milwaukee)
Eleanor Holmes Norton (DC) (Washington, D.C.)
Donald M. Payne, Jr. (NJ-10) (Newark)
Charles B. Rangel (NY-13) (Upper Manhattan) 
Bobby L. Rush (IL-01) (Chicago-Joliet)
Robert C. "Bobby" Scott (VA-03) (Newport News-Norfolk-Richmond)
Maxine Waters (CA-43) (South Los Angeles County)

Roughly 6 percent of Americans are represented by one of these 27 members of the House. If you belong to this 6 percent, then you are special, because they are special.

If you are a member of this 6 percent group of special Americans, then I encourage you to call your representative (you can look up their phone number here) and urge them to make a public statement now in favor of lifting the blockade on 1.8 million human beings in Gaza. Time is pressing, because negotiations are happening in Cairo right now that are likely to have a decisive impact on whether and when the blockade is ended.

If you belong to the other 94 percent, then I encourage you to look at the list of 27 districts above and send the link to this post to someone you know who lives in one of those 27 districts.

Let's form an ad-hoc "pressure group" to try to turn the CBC in favor of ending the economic blockade of 1.8 million Palestinians in Gaza. If we succeed, yay for us. If we fail, we won't fail because we chose a quixotic strategy; we'll fail because we couldn't recruit enough pragmatic engagers to carry it out.

Copyright, Truthout. May not be reprinted without permission.

Robert Naiman

Robert Naiman is policy director at Just Foreign Policy and president of Truthout's board of directors. 

Related Stories

Gaza Hospitals Can't Cope
By Mohammed Omer, Truthout | Report
Gaza On Fire
By Staff, Truthout | Special Features
Another Descent Into Hell
By Richard Lichtman, Truthout | Op-Ed
Israel and Palestine Can Never Be Secure Until Both Are Secure
By Michael Nagler, Truthout | Op-Ed
Noam Chomsky | Nightmare in Gaza
By Noam Chomsky, Truthout | Op-Ed

Hide Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus
GET DAILY TRUTHOUT UPDATES

FOLLOW togtorsstottofb


Latest Stories

Black Caucus: #StandWithKeith to End Gaza Blockade

Wednesday, 06 August 2014 11:35 By Robert Naiman, Truthout | Op-Ed

2014 806 keath stCongressman Keath Ellison, co-chair of the Congressional Progressive Caucus (Photo: Aaron Landry / Flickr)On July 29, Congressional Progressive Caucus Co-Chair Keith Ellison did something unique for a member of Congress. He published an op-ed in The Washington Post calling for ending the economic blockade on 1.8 million Palestinians in Gaza, noting that most of the victims of the blockade were women and children.

As of this writing, Representative Ellison stands alone among members of Congress in calling for the economic blockade on civilians in Gaza to end.

"Every schoolboy knows" that the so-called "pro-Israel lobby," i.e. the lobby pushing for US policy on any issue of interest to the Israeli government to be determined to the greatest extent possible by the Israeli Likud party, has tremendous influence in Washington and especially in Congress. The generally accepted shorthand for this pro-Likud lobby is "AIPAC." (It's common practice to use the term "AIPAC" to refer to the pro-Likud lobby generically, including such groups as the (so-called) Anti-Defamation League (ADL) and the American Jewish Committee (AJC), rather than merely to the activities of the American Israel Public Affairs Committee per se, much as one uses the term "Xerox" to mean "copy." I will follow this practice here, using the term "AIPAC" to refer to the pro-Likud lobby more generally.)

But here is a crucial fact that is largely unacknowledged: Until now, there is no consistent, strategic, coordinated effort by DC-focused reformists to reduce the harm caused by AIPAC to US policy on the Israel-Palestine issue, with the goal of opening political space for concrete measures to support a realistic diplomatic resolution of issues related to the Israel-Palestine conflict, similar to the coordinated efforts that have opened political space for diplomatic efforts to resolve the US-Iran conflict over Iran's nuclear program. There is a vacuum of pragmatic, reformist leadership to try to limit AIPAC's destructive influence on US policy towards Israel-Palestine.

If there were not such a vacuum, Keith Ellison would not be standing alone. 

On the one hand, there are reformist groups. Unfortunately, at this juncture, the historic fulcrum of these groups appears to be too obsessed with getting the approval of pro-AIPAC Jewish communal institutions to be relied on to consistently lead a reformist effort that moves the ball forward in Washington on Israel-Palestine. On the other hand, there are non-reformist groups on the left, which are incapable of leading strategically because they are obsessed with quixotic fantasies of cutting US military aid to Israel, or of opposing AIPAC "yay Israel" resolutions that are unstoppable. These so-called "strategies" don't pass the minimal "one member of Congress" test for a non-quixotic DC strategy. The "one member of Congress" test for a non-quixotic DC strategy is: Could you get one member of Congress to lead it? If not, then you're not on the playing field of Washington, and have no hope of getting there.

Quixotic efforts are counterproductive over the long term to engagement and mobilization. If you mobilize people for a quixotic strategy, they're likely to be discouraged when the strategy predictably goes down in flames. They're likely to conclude that engagement is useless, but it was the pursuit of a quixotic strategy that caused their demoralization, not engagement per se. When people win, they do more. When they lose, they do less. It's a moral responsibility of a strategist to try to create opportunities for people to win.

Pushing to end the economic blockade of 1.8 million Palestinian human beings in Gaza is passing the "one member of Congress" test, because Rep. Keith Ellison is in the house. So here's a strategy that could potentially be on the playing field of Washington right now: Let's try to get other members of Congress to #StandWithKeith in favor of ending the economic blockade on 1.8 million Palestinians in Gaza.

We have to start somewhere. Where should we begin?

Twenty-seven members of the House have two things in common:

1) like Keith Ellison, they signed the July 2013 Dent-Price letter backing the Obama administration's diplomatic engagement with Iran, in defiance of AIPAC, and 

2) like Keith Ellison, they are members of the Congressional Black Caucus (CBC).

Why is this group of 27 members of Congress so special?

When Ellison sent a letter on July 18, calling for intensifying US diplomacy to end the war in Gaza, two-thirds of the signers were CBC members (like Ellison) who had signed the Dent-Price letter. Twenty-eight (67 percent) of the 42 House members of the CBC (including Ellison) signed the Dent-Price letter. So, while CBC signers of the Dent-Price letter comprised 6 percent of the House, they comprised 67 percent of the signers of the Ellison cease-fire letter. That's why these 27 members of the House are special.


Here they are, with their districts and some geography:

Karen Bass (CA-37) (Los Angeles/Culver City)
Sanford D. Bishop, Jr. (GA-02) (SW Georgia, Columbus-Cordele-Bainbridge)
André Carson (IN-07) (Indianapolis)
Donna M. Christensen (VI) (Virgin Islands)
Wm. Lacy Clay (MO-01) (St. Louis)
Emanuel Cleaver, II (MO-05) (Kansas City)
James E. Clyburn (SC-06) (SE South Carolina, Charleston-Columbia)
John Conyers, Jr. (MI-13) (Detroit)
Elijah E. Cummings (MD-07) (Baltimore)
Danny K. Davis (IL-07) (Chicago-Oak Park)
Donna F. Edwards (MD-04) (Prince George's, Montgomery, Anne Arundel Counties)
Chaka Fattah (PA-02) (Philadelphia)
Alcee L. Hastings (FL-20) (Miami)
Sheila Jackson Lee (TX-18) (Houston)
Eddie Bernice Johnson (TX-30) (Dallas)
Hank Johnson (GA-04) (Atlanta-Decatur, DeKalb County)
Robin Kelly (IL-02) (Chicago-Kankakee)
Barbara Lee (CA-13) (Berkeley-Oakland)
John Lewis (GA-05) (Atlanta)
Gregory W. Meeks (NY-06) (Queens)
Gwen Moore (WI-04) (Milwaukee)
Eleanor Holmes Norton (DC) (Washington, D.C.)
Donald M. Payne, Jr. (NJ-10) (Newark)
Charles B. Rangel (NY-13) (Upper Manhattan) 
Bobby L. Rush (IL-01) (Chicago-Joliet)
Robert C. "Bobby" Scott (VA-03) (Newport News-Norfolk-Richmond)
Maxine Waters (CA-43) (South Los Angeles County)

Roughly 6 percent of Americans are represented by one of these 27 members of the House. If you belong to this 6 percent, then you are special, because they are special.

If you are a member of this 6 percent group of special Americans, then I encourage you to call your representative (you can look up their phone number here) and urge them to make a public statement now in favor of lifting the blockade on 1.8 million human beings in Gaza. Time is pressing, because negotiations are happening in Cairo right now that are likely to have a decisive impact on whether and when the blockade is ended.

If you belong to the other 94 percent, then I encourage you to look at the list of 27 districts above and send the link to this post to someone you know who lives in one of those 27 districts.

Let's form an ad-hoc "pressure group" to try to turn the CBC in favor of ending the economic blockade of 1.8 million Palestinians in Gaza. If we succeed, yay for us. If we fail, we won't fail because we chose a quixotic strategy; we'll fail because we couldn't recruit enough pragmatic engagers to carry it out.

Copyright, Truthout. May not be reprinted without permission.

Robert Naiman

Robert Naiman is policy director at Just Foreign Policy and president of Truthout's board of directors. 

Related Stories

Gaza Hospitals Can't Cope
By Mohammed Omer, Truthout | Report
Gaza On Fire
By Staff, Truthout | Special Features
Another Descent Into Hell
By Richard Lichtman, Truthout | Op-Ed
Israel and Palestine Can Never Be Secure Until Both Are Secure
By Michael Nagler, Truthout | Op-Ed
Noam Chomsky | Nightmare in Gaza
By Noam Chomsky, Truthout | Op-Ed

Hide Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus