Tuesday, 23 September 2014 / TRUTH-OUT.ORG

After Calling the Auto Rescue "Tragic," Mitt Romney Now Claims He "Had the Idea First"

Wednesday, 25 May 2011 09:11 By Tanya Somanader, ThinkProgress | Report
After Calling the Auto Rescue Tragic Mitt Romney Now Claims He Had the Idea First

Mitt Romney, a former governor of Massachusetts, speaks to supporter, Jennifer Fung, in North Las Vegas, Nevada, April 1, 2011. (Photo: Ronda Churchill / The New York Times)

The Obama administration’s decision to rescue General Motors, Ford, and Chrysler in 2008 spurred hyperbolic criticism from Republicans who viewed the financial aid as “the road to socialism” and “a war on capitalism.” However, as the Wonk Room’s Pat Garofalo reported, the companies are regaining strength and proving profitable once again. Indeed, not only is General Motors set to add 2,500 jobs at its Detroit plant, but Chrysler recently paid back $7.5 billion in government loans. In view of the auto recovery’s success, “the GOP hasn’t been advertising its previous denunciations.”

In fact, one outspoken critic is now actually trying to take credit for the auto rescue: GOP presidential candidate Mitt Romney. Slamming Obama’s decision as “tragic” and “a very sad circumstance for this country” in 2009, Romney’s camp is now actually claiming that “Mitt Romney had the idea first“:

A Romney spokesman said on Tuesday that the president’s plan was modeled after one Mr. Romney advocated in 2008.

“Mitt Romney had the idea first,” said Eric Fehrnstrom, a Romney spokesman, citing the Times opinion article. “You have to acknowledge that. He was advocating for a course of action that eventually the Obama administration adopted.”

But Mr. Fehrnstrom also accused Mr. Obama of wasting billions of dollars “propping up” the auto companies as part of the government’s restructuring plans for the industry.

“Mitt Romney argued that instead of a bailout, we should let the car companies go through a restructuring under the bankruptcy laws,” Mr. Fehrnstrom said.

The degree of amnesia necessary for such a claim is pretty stark. After all, in 2008, Romney flatly stated that if General Motors and Chrysler “get the bailout,” “you can kiss the American automotive industry goodbye. It won’t go overnight, but its demise will be virtually guaranteed.” The title of his op-ed incidentally is “Let Detroit Go Bankrupt“:

A plan, Democratic officials noted, that had already occurred: “Chrysler and General Motors received the federal aid only after they entered bankruptcy — not before, as Mr. Romney’s spokesman asserted.” Because “the bankruptcy’s success depended on the federal money,” Romney’s model would have failed.

But such a 180 degree reversal seems only natural for Romney. Be it climate change, immigration, his own health care plan, or even Ronald Reagan, Romney has impressive credentials as a flip flopper. Thus, former Gov. Jennifer Granholm’s (D-MI) observation that “Mitt Romney is doing circuslike contortions to get out from under the damaging words he uttered in 2008″ should come as no surprise.

Tanya Somanader

Tanya Somanader is a Reporter/Blogger for Think Progress and The Progress Report at American Progress. Prior to joining ThinkProgress, Tanya was a staff member in the Office of Sen. Sherrod Brown (D-Ohio) since 2007 working on issues ranging from foreign policy and defense to civil rights and social policy.


Hide Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus
GET DAILY TRUTHOUT UPDATES

FOLLOW togtorsstottofb


After Calling the Auto Rescue "Tragic," Mitt Romney Now Claims He "Had the Idea First"

Wednesday, 25 May 2011 09:11 By Tanya Somanader, ThinkProgress | Report
After Calling the Auto Rescue Tragic Mitt Romney Now Claims He Had the Idea First

Mitt Romney, a former governor of Massachusetts, speaks to supporter, Jennifer Fung, in North Las Vegas, Nevada, April 1, 2011. (Photo: Ronda Churchill / The New York Times)

The Obama administration’s decision to rescue General Motors, Ford, and Chrysler in 2008 spurred hyperbolic criticism from Republicans who viewed the financial aid as “the road to socialism” and “a war on capitalism.” However, as the Wonk Room’s Pat Garofalo reported, the companies are regaining strength and proving profitable once again. Indeed, not only is General Motors set to add 2,500 jobs at its Detroit plant, but Chrysler recently paid back $7.5 billion in government loans. In view of the auto recovery’s success, “the GOP hasn’t been advertising its previous denunciations.”

In fact, one outspoken critic is now actually trying to take credit for the auto rescue: GOP presidential candidate Mitt Romney. Slamming Obama’s decision as “tragic” and “a very sad circumstance for this country” in 2009, Romney’s camp is now actually claiming that “Mitt Romney had the idea first“:

A Romney spokesman said on Tuesday that the president’s plan was modeled after one Mr. Romney advocated in 2008.

“Mitt Romney had the idea first,” said Eric Fehrnstrom, a Romney spokesman, citing the Times opinion article. “You have to acknowledge that. He was advocating for a course of action that eventually the Obama administration adopted.”

But Mr. Fehrnstrom also accused Mr. Obama of wasting billions of dollars “propping up” the auto companies as part of the government’s restructuring plans for the industry.

“Mitt Romney argued that instead of a bailout, we should let the car companies go through a restructuring under the bankruptcy laws,” Mr. Fehrnstrom said.

The degree of amnesia necessary for such a claim is pretty stark. After all, in 2008, Romney flatly stated that if General Motors and Chrysler “get the bailout,” “you can kiss the American automotive industry goodbye. It won’t go overnight, but its demise will be virtually guaranteed.” The title of his op-ed incidentally is “Let Detroit Go Bankrupt“:

A plan, Democratic officials noted, that had already occurred: “Chrysler and General Motors received the federal aid only after they entered bankruptcy — not before, as Mr. Romney’s spokesman asserted.” Because “the bankruptcy’s success depended on the federal money,” Romney’s model would have failed.

But such a 180 degree reversal seems only natural for Romney. Be it climate change, immigration, his own health care plan, or even Ronald Reagan, Romney has impressive credentials as a flip flopper. Thus, former Gov. Jennifer Granholm’s (D-MI) observation that “Mitt Romney is doing circuslike contortions to get out from under the damaging words he uttered in 2008″ should come as no surprise.

Tanya Somanader

Tanya Somanader is a Reporter/Blogger for Think Progress and The Progress Report at American Progress. Prior to joining ThinkProgress, Tanya was a staff member in the Office of Sen. Sherrod Brown (D-Ohio) since 2007 working on issues ranging from foreign policy and defense to civil rights and social policy.


Hide Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus